Shingles vs Metal Roofing: Which is Better for Arnold, MO Homes?
You need a new roof.
You are looking at a substantial investment, and you have two main choices:
1. The Classic Asphalt Shingle.
2. The Modern Metal Roof.
Historically, 95% of Arnold homes used shingles. They were cheap, available, and "good enough."
But in recent years? We are installing more metal roofs than ever before.
So, which one is right for your home, your budget, and your future plans?
As experts in both shingle replacement and metal roofing in Arnold, we have broken down the battle between these two materials.
1. Asphalt Shingles (The Local Favorite)
This is the standard. If you drive through any subdivision in Jefferson County, this is what you see.
Modern shingles are "Architectural" or "Dimensional"—meaning they are thick, layered, and designed to look good.
The Pros:
Cost: It is the most affordable option. Period. If budget is your #1 concern, shingles win.
Style: They come in endless colors. We install Owens Corning shingles that mimic the look of slate or wood shake.
Walkability: You (or a technician) can walk on them easily to clean gutters or hang Christmas lights.
Repairs: Very easy. If a storm blows a tab off, we just nail a new one on.
The Cons:
Lifespan: In Missouri's fluctuating weather, asphalt shingles typically last 20–25 years.
Heat Absorption: Dark shingles absorb the summer sun. This makes your attic hot, forcing your AC to work harder.
(Wondering about the price tag? See ourCost Guide here.)
2. Metal Roofing (The "Forever" Roof)
Metal is the rising star. It looks sleek, modern, and stands out from the neighbors.
We typically install Standing Seam Metal Roofing, where the fasteners are hidden underneath the panels so they never rust or leak.
The Pros:
Longevity: A properly installed metal roof can last 50 to 70 years. It is likely the last roof you will ever buy.
Energy Efficiency: Metal reflects solar radiant heat. This can lower your summer cooling bills by 20% or more.
Toughness: It is fireproof, rot-proof, and insect-proof.
Resale Value: A metal roof is a major selling point that can increase your home’s value.
The Cons:
Price: Expect to pay 2x to 3x more upfront than shingles.
Noise: Some people love the sound of rain on a tin roof; others find it loud (though proper attic insulation minimizes this).
Dents: Large hail won't break the metal, but it can leave cosmetic dents that might bug you.
3. Battle of the Elements: Missouri Edition
How do these materials handle the specific weather threats we face in Arnold?
Wind:
Metal: Wins hands down. Many systems are rated for winds up to 140 mph.
Shingles: Can lift, tear, or blow off in a tornado or severe straight-line winds.
Hail:
Metal: Wins on leak prevention. It might get dented, but it rarely punctures.
Shingles: Hail knocks the granules off shingles. This "bruises" the matting and leads to premature failure.
Ice Dams:
Metal: Snow slides right off metal roofs (which is good for the roof, but watch your head!).
Shingles: Snow sits and melts, potentially causing ice dams if your ventilation is poor.
4. The HOA Factor (Critical Step)
Stop. Before you fall in love with a metal roof, check your rules.
Some subdivisions in Arnold and Imperial have strict covenants (HOA rules). They might require "Asphalt Shingles Only" to maintain a uniform look.
Pro Tip: If you are stuck with shingles but want a premium look, ask us about Designer Shingles. Brands like Owens Corning make heavy-duty shingles that look exactly like slate tile but satisfy HOA requirements.
The Verdict: Which Should You Choose?
Choose Asphalt Shingles If:
You want the most cost-effective solution.
You plan to move in the next 5–10 years.
Your HOA strictly forbids metal.
Choose Metal Roofing If:
This is your "forever home."
You want to save money on monthly energy bills.
You never want to deal with the noise and mess of a roof replacement again.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Does a metal roof attract lightning?
A: No. Metal roofs do not increase the likelihood of a lightning strike. In fact, because they are non-combustible, they are safer than wood or asphalt if lightning does strike.
Q: Can I put metal over my old shingles?
A: We advise against it. Just like with shingles, we want to tear off the old roof to inspect the decking for rot. A solid foundation is key to a 50-year roof.
Still undecided?
We can bring samples of both materials to your kitchen table.
See the colors. Touch the materials. Get a side-by-side price comparison.
> Request your material consultation in Arnold.
